Surface Warp Protocol Overview
Given a collection of surfaces and anatomical landmarks on those surfaces, this process warps the surfaces such that all of the surface's vertices are anatomically homologous.
In particular, we expect a collection of subjects. Each subject must have an octahedrally-triangulated cortical surface object and a collection of anatomical landmarks, defined by contours whose vertices lie on the given surface.
These are the major steps of the process:
- For each subject, map the three-dimensional surfaces and contours on that surface to a two-dimensional manifold
- For each contour across subjects, average the contours in the two-dimensional manifold, creating the atlas
- For each subject, compute the elastic warp in the two-dimensional manifold that maps the atlas contours to the subject contours
- Apply the warp to the two-dimensional surface coordinate and color data
- Map the warped surface data to the ambient three-dimensional space for further processing and statistical analysis
There are two types implementations of the protocol, namely a LONI Pipeline workflow and a command line interface. There are also two implementations of the warping stage of the protocol, namely the Octahedral warping method and the Dual warping method.
Implementation Choice: Octahedral or Dual
There are two implementations of the warping. They differ in how they handle the topology (connectedness) of the domain, which is spherical. The first implementation, the Dual Surface Warp Protocol, reproduces the existing protocol by Paul Thompson. This approach solves for two topologically-planar warps and blends the results, handling the topology at a high level. The second implementation, the Octahedral Surface Warp Protocol, solves for the warp given the octahedral topology, handling the topology at a low level.
When a topologically-spherical surface is parameterized, there are a number of ways this may be done. Each way defines a different and artificial boundary. For shapes with an octahedral triangulation, there are six simple and equivalent ways to parameterize the space. Note: technically there are more parameterizations but all others are equivalent to these six by a rotation and translation of the coordinates. These parameterizations can be imagined by viewing the octahedron from above and cutting the edges that are farthest and folding up the four far faces while flattening the closest four faces. This creates a square flattening of the octahedron where the farthest vertex is mapped to all four corners, the closest vertex is mapped to the center and the remaining four vertices are mapped to the edges of the square. The six parameterizations are the found by viewing the octahedron from each of the six vertices.
In the Dual Surface Warp Protocol, two complementary parameterizations are used; they're called the "non-dual" and "dual" representations. The warp is computed with zero displacement at the boundary of these domains. Since we would like a warp to be defined without this artificial boundary condition, the warp is computed in each of these complementary domains, and the final warp will be a "blending" of the warps in each of these spaces. In this method, contours must be represented in both the non-dual and dual representations. Furthermore, when computing the warp, contours that cross the representations boundary are excluded. Note that is is possible for a contour to cross the boundary in both representations, which means it is excluded from the warp entirely. In addition, the choice of which complementary representations to use may change the contours included and the resulting warp.
In the Octahedral Surface Warp Protocol, instead of choosing two representations to use to compute the warp, all six are utilized by choosing the most appropriate parameterization for a given point when the warp is being computed, transforming the neighboring values accordingly. The principal difference between this method and the "dual" method is that this method accounts for the topology when the warp is being computed, and the "dual" method accounts for the topology after the two warps have been computed.
The octahedral method encapsulates the complexity of handling the topology, so the analysis requires fewer files and programs. The octahedral method also has the benefit of including all contours, and there is a symmetry to the method that eliminates the choice of representations and the effect of that choice on the results. However, the octahedral method will take several hours longer than the dual method with equal numbers of iterations.
Implementation Choice: Pipeline or Command Line
The user may run the protocol as either a LONI Pipeline workflow or a command line script. The choice depends on user preference more than anything.
The Pipeline workflow provides a simple interface with informative visualizations of the process's progress. Furthermore, the error reporting in the Pipeline is very direct and easy to interpret.
The command line interface is a collection of scripts that implement the protocol. This method is best suited for those with experience with *NIX and the Sun Grid Engine. The command line interface is very simple when all data is well-formed. Diagnosing errors can require a good deal of skill on the command line. When an error occurs, the user must be able to search logs and remove jobs from the grid queue. The benefit of this implementation is fine-grained control of the process. If the user wishes to only perform part of the analysis, this method can be easier than changing the Pipeline workflow.